I think there will be plenty going on in New Moon without the proposal (which i don't class as the proper proposal anyway). It will make a better, more dramatic scene when Edward does it properly - on one knee, with a beautiful ring. It will give us something more to look forward too in Eclipse, and I don't think its vital they have it in New Moon. I don't think any of us are going to be disappointed come Nov 09 !! lets all just look forward to New Moon and not stress/worry over things we have no control over.
The marriage proposal is the main part of eclipse not new moon. And it will be included in that film I would bet. And new moon and rest of sagas are and will be very close to the book as that what Stephanie wants to be.
The proposal has to be in New Moon as it's important to have as it leads into early Eclipse.
The proposal is the condition that Edward gives her after they return after the vote at the Cullens' house.
It also shows he's willing to give her what she wants even if he doesn't want to turn her & end her life.
It shows another depth of how much he loves her.
It's very important to include in this movie and if it's left out or not put in at all, what will this do to Eclipse?
If they are staying more closely to the book like every one of the cast members have been saying, how can they stay close to the book and exclude one of the most important scenes towards the end that leads to Eclipse?
I hope that the rumors are wrong and that we will see the proposal in New Moon.
I can't belive it!!!!!!! I agree that the proposal thing would be the best thing in the movie......
Theyb should just keep everything in the book the same in the movie, It sucks when they change everything and take out the best parts!!!!!!!
Not sure how much we should believe of this Edwards proposal is key to the saga, but scriptwriters & director may have other ideas and perhaps feature the proposal scene more in Eclipse rather than New Moon.
ok well i'm getting confused, becuz i read some where that the scene is not cut out from the movie n now i read this. Maybe they are trying to confuse us becuz one minute the scene is in and the next its out. We will just have to stay anxious and excited until Nov 20th. That proposal is a key part of the story its how he got her to calm down n not going running to Carlise to change her. It has to be in the movie. you cant jus bring up in Eclipse like that.