Should they split Breaking Dawn into two movies to cover all topics?
Okay so its rumored that they are going to make two movies out of Breaking Dawn to be able to cover all topics thoroughly. Although I like the idea of them being observant and following the book...I do not want to wait for Breaking Dawn 2 to come out prob a year after Breaking Dawn. So what do you think?
And the results are in!!! See what Summit has come up with here.
And the results are in!!! See what Summit has come up with here.
Tags: breaking, dawn, movies, separate, two
Views: 1
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by twilightitca on -
i believe that the best corse of action is the 2 movies.
just imagine how long will the in one!
3 hours?
maybe!
-
Permalink Reply by J.E.B. (Jacob Edward Black) on -
tough one....I want the movie done right.....hate to wait....be patient....shut up!......someone else figure it out.........lol
the return of the king was over 2 hours almost 3 i think......
-
Permalink Reply by Amber Hoyt on -
When I read the book, that was one of the first thoughts that I had. The story itself seems set up well for 2 movies. The climax where Bella has the baby and becomes a vampire and then when the voultari attack would work for both. I also think they need to tuck the wedding at the end of Eclips rather then the beginning of breaking dawn. Especially so if they only do one movie. They could make it work in 1 movie they would just leave out a lot of stuff. Lets just hope some pillow bitting stays in. lol!
-
Permalink Reply by Book wormie** on -
UGH!! Such a hard topic! Well on one hand you have one whole movie w/ a lot of details missing, on the other hand you have two movies w/ almost all the details ... BUT where in the book would they end the movie? Everything happens right after bella has renesmee basically. IT'S too hard. oh and then the movies would be like one 2 hours long and then then the other one would probably be 1:50hr. it's kinda bogus!! BUT I DON'T KNOW!!! it's two hard i'll wait for the movie.
Here's another thing .... What will it be rated?? i'm under 18 so it can't be R! I hope it's PG-13!! PRAYING!!
-
Permalink Reply by Southern Pattinson on -
No that is one thing that they said is they were keeping the PG-13 rating b/c their prime target audience is teens. So I dont think you'll have to worry about that, although we all kno how graphic Breaking Dawn is & they will have to cut out alot of details to avoid the R rating.
Book wormie** said:UGH!! Such a hard topic! Well on one hand you have one whole movie w/ a lot of details missing, on the other hand you have two movies w/ almost all the details ... BUT where in the book would they end the movie? Everything happens right after bella has renesmee basically. IT'S too hard. oh and then the movies would be like one 2 hours long and then then the other one would probably be 1:50hr. it's kinda bogus!! BUT I DON'T KNOW!!! it's two hard i'll wait for the movie.
Here's another thing .... What will it be rated?? i'm under 18 so it can't be R! I hope it's PG-13!! PRAYING!!
-
Permalink Reply by Lana on -
I think it'll be better to split it into 2 movies. It has too much content for just 1( otherwise its gonna 1 long ass movie).
-
Permalink Reply by Olympia on -
it would be better if the made it into two movies because BD is the best book of all series and it wouldn't be right with just one movie.. i think that the best idea is to make the first movie ending with Renessme's birth and then the second one beginning with Bella as newborn vampire! that would be awesome!!!!:D
-
Permalink Reply by Southern Pattinson on
-
I agree!
Olympia said:it would be better if the made it into two movies because BD is the best book of all series and it wouldn't be right with just one movie.. i think that the best idea is to make the first movie ending with Renessme's birth and then the second one beginning with Bella as newborn vampire! that would be awesome!!!!:D
-
Permalink Reply by Sophie Cullen on -
I think it's best to have 2 movies if they get more of the story that way : )
-
Permalink Reply by KKS on -
I would love to see it done in two parts because there is so much to say and cover with the final book. It needs to be given the proper time to wrap the series up on film. Anything short of 3 hours would not be doing the book justice and 3 hours is a long movie!! 2 movies would be much better!!
-
Permalink Reply by LuvMeSumEdward on -
I would rather them do two movies than to leave out half of the book trying to cram it all into one movie. There's just too much happening in Breaking Dawn to fit it into one movie. I would much rather have it done RIGHT with all the good stuff where it needs to be and have to wait for the second movie than to get one crappy movie. Patience is a virtue! And - all GOOD things come to those who wait! It will be torture, but it would be worth it in the end.
-
Permalink Reply by Bella_swan on -
2 movies def. For me, 1st would be the wedding and pregnancy (that will be the book1 and 2 of BD) and 2nd's the book 3. BD is my favorite book. I like eclipse but i hate it when bella realizes she loves Jacob but i like jacob on BD specially book 2-the jacob's perspective, it's quite funny.
© 2013
Site Created & Designed By:
