which scenes you didnt like in twilight saga movies? after they changed it from the book?

there are alot of scenes ,they changed it from the book..which scenes, they changed it and you didnt like it ?

in twilight , newmoon : they changed alot of scenes but i loved them all..

but in eclipse, the scenes in the book were much better like :

1-rosalie's flashback - in the book she went after bella to edward's room and talked to her in very nice way..i really felt sorry for wht happened to her..she talked about her self , why she doesnt like bella -all the reasons , not just cuz bella is human... but in the movie , they made bella go after rosalie and rosalie talked to her in away made me nervs..
*Go blather to someone else about the joys of becoming a newborn.* why they changed that?
i felt sorry for her--- in the book , not the movie , but i hated her in BD..

2- the scene before the battle when jacob heard bella and edward when they were talking about their marriage..bella became very angry with edward..WHYYYYYYYY THEY CHANGED THAT?
in the book , she was sad for hurting him , edward went after him to bring him to talk to bella..
i shocked when i saw that they changed it in the movie ..
also she was angry with him when they met jacob at school , but i liked it..may be , she did that
to hung out with jacob for awhile..=DDD

Views: 232

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

New Moon- in the movie Bella tells Jacob that she loves him that wasn't in the book!!

Eclipse- in the movie Bella rides of with Jacob on his bike infront of Edward in the book its Alice.. Why They Changed That I Have No Idea!!

Eclipse- in the movie the ending in the meadow its always been about Edward why they changed that I don't know!!

But I also agree with you about the scene before the battle!! You're right Sara there was alot that they changed!!

 

Twilight - When they testing which blood type the class was and Bella nearly passed out (They didn't add this to the movie but I think it's a very ironic scene! A vampires gf hating blood! lol)

New Moon - Jacob and Bella get a lot closer in the book than in the film and in the book Bella thinks Edward isn't real and she thinks she has gone crazy or something which I think they should have added to the film.

Eclipse - Alice doesn't 'kidnap' Bella for the sleepover! Also when Jacob kissed Bella in the book she was soo angry which showed how strongly she felt for Edward but in the movie you just saw Edward angry! Also the ending is so much better in the book! They cut out the "i want you bella" stuff out :l

Emma I couldn't agree more with you about the blood typing scene from Twilight.  I think it was a crucial part to the story and really showed a lot of irony.  I also loved how Edward  carried her to the nurses office, I can't get enough of his chivalry.  Even in the end of Twilight when James has acted her and she is bleeding she referred to the blood.  Oh and remember when Edward said she didn't smell right after the blood transfusions?

 

Can you explain the part you are referring to in Eclipse when he tells her he wants her???  I am lost....  my bad need to read the book again.
Emma Louise said:

Twilight - When they testing which blood type the class was and Bella nearly passed out (They didn't add this to the movie but I think it's a very ironic scene! A vampires gf hating blood! lol)

New Moon - Jacob and Bella get a lot closer in the book than in the film and in the book Bella thinks Edward isn't real and she thinks she has gone crazy or something which I think they should have added to the film.

Eclipse - Alice doesn't 'kidnap' Bella for the sleepover! Also when Jacob kissed Bella in the book she was soo angry which showed how strongly she felt for Edward but in the movie you just saw Edward angry! Also the ending is so much better in the book! They cut out the "i want you bella" stuff out :l

Twilight I definitley agree with Emma about the blood type scene, I feel like it was crucial to the story.  In addition I don't think they should have left out the part when Bella was in the hospital and Edward told her she smelled all wrong after getting blood transfusions.

What about when Edward ran and she was on his back and she would get sick.  I think it is odd they didn't show this.

 

New Moon I think it would have been more interesting if they would have had the visit to the Volturi more like the book.  Like when they had to go down a h*** and Alice stood at bottom and caught Bella.  Also they should have had to wait to leave until night.  Lastly, I loved when they returned home from Italy and Edward carried her to her room.  I think they should have showed this part as well.

 

Eclipse.......well I think I need to read it again :)

 

I wasn't too worried about any changes to the first two.  I expected most things they changed.  Eclipse was completely different, as they didn't just change scenes, they made the characters' behaviour contrary to the book, such as in the motorcycle scene and the final scene (how they ever thought they'd get away with the motorcycle scene is beyond me!). 

I didn't like Jessica Stanley being valedictorian, either.  It doesn't match up with her character at all.  Giving those lines to her character just because of the actress who plays her is, I think, a bit too self-indulgent.

I think when she is referring to Edward saying that he wants one on one time with Bella, to have time where they only think about each other and no one else.


Also I was majorly disappointed when they did not do the Blood-typing scene in Twilight I thought it was very important and also when Edward questions her about her opinions about just about everything. But I guess they cant put in everything.
Jo Anna said:

Emma I couldn't agree more with you about the blood typing scene from Twilight.  I think it was a crucial part to the story and really showed a lot of irony.  I also loved how Edward  carried her to the nurses office, I can't get enough of his chivalry.  Even in the end of Twilight when James has acted her and she is bleeding she referred to the blood.  Oh and remember when Edward said she didn't smell right after the blood transfusions?

 

Can you explain the part you are referring to in Eclipse when he tells her he wants her???  I am lost....  my bad need to read the book again.
Emma Louise said:

Twilight - When they testing which blood type the class was and Bella nearly passed out (They didn't add this to the movie but I think it's a very ironic scene! A vampires gf hating blood! lol)

New Moon - Jacob and Bella get a lot closer in the book than in the film and in the book Bella thinks Edward isn't real and she thinks she has gone crazy or something which I think they should have added to the film.

Eclipse - Alice doesn't 'kidnap' Bella for the sleepover! Also when Jacob kissed Bella in the book she was soo angry which showed how strongly she felt for Edward but in the movie you just saw Edward angry! Also the ending is so much better in the book! They cut out the "i want you bella" stuff out :l

Remind me was Jessica valedictorian in the book?

Tornado said:

I wasn't too worried about any changes to the first two.  I expected most things they changed.  Eclipse was completely different, as they didn't just change scenes, they made the characters' behaviour contrary to the book, such as in the motorcycle scene and the final scene (how they ever thought they'd get away with the motorcycle scene is beyond me!). 

I didn't like Jessica Stanley being valedictorian, either.  It doesn't match up with her character at all.  Giving those lines to her character just because of the actress who plays her is, I think, a bit too self-indulgent.

No, Eric was valedictorian in the book.  You can imagine it with his character.  It could have worked with Angela's character too.  But not Jessica's.
I really need to brush up on my reading of Eclipse.....  Yes, Eric so ideal and Angela as well.

Tornado said:
No, Eric was valedictorian in the book.  You can imagine it with his character.  It could have worked with Angela's character too.  But not Jessica's.

I agree w/everything you guys have said. Also inn TW the 1st meadow scene where Edward reveals himself to Bella. That was REALLY different from the book & even in a different part of the storyline! Why'd the do that? That chapter/scene in the book is what started Twilight (from SM's dream.)

 

I think the part she's refering to where Edward tells Bella he wants her is at the end. After they go to to tell Alice that she can plan the wedding they go to their meadow. And they are talking about the wedding & Edward asks Bella why she is doing this & they they start making out & Edward is really into it & then Bella stops saying she wants to do it "the right way"  and he asks her whose right way & she says hers & she stops them from basically making love for the first time right there in the meadow.



Jo Anna said:

Emma I couldn't agree more with you about the blood typing scene from Twilight.  I think it was a crucial part to the story and really showed a lot of irony.  I also loved how Edward  carried her to the nurses office, I can't get enough of his chivalry.  Even in the end of Twilight when James has acted her and she is bleeding she referred to the blood.  Oh and remember when Edward said she didn't smell right after the blood transfusions?

 

Can you explain the part you are referring to in Eclipse when he tells her he wants her???  I am lost....  my bad need to read the book again.
Emma Louise said:

Twilight - When they testing which blood type the class was and Bella nearly passed out (They didn't add this to the movie but I think it's a very ironic scene! A vampires gf hating blood! lol)

New Moon - Jacob and Bella get a lot closer in the book than in the film and in the book Bella thinks Edward isn't real and she thinks she has gone crazy or something which I think they should have added to the film.

Eclipse - Alice doesn't 'kidnap' Bella for the sleepover! Also when Jacob kissed Bella in the book she was soo angry which showed how strongly she felt for Edward but in the movie you just saw Edward angry! Also the ending is so much better in the book! They cut out the "i want you bella" stuff out :l

@Pennybug  I have been reading Twilight again while reading Breaking Dawn again as well.  I too noticed the sequence of things is way off.  It actually was a little confusing.  I really feel like they left some key scenes out of the movie.  I wished they wouldn't have skipped scenes because it is the foundation of pretty much the entire story.  You know it never made sense to me why Edward's eyes weren't red after drinking Bella's blood when he was sucking out the venom.  I could go on for hours....  none the less I still love the movie watched it last night then woke up in middle of night to reading Breaking Dawn....  I think I might need help..lol

 

I am curious to know more about your reference talking about where Stephanie's dream began.  I am not familiar.


Pennybug Cullen said:

I agree w/everything you guys have said. Also inn TW the 1st meadow scene where Edward reveals himself to Bella. That was REALLY different from the book & even in a different part of the storyline! Why'd the do that? That chapter/scene in the book is what started Twilight (from SM's dream.)

 

I think the part she's refering to where Edward tells Bella he wants her is at the end. After they go to to tell Alice that she can plan the wedding they go to their meadow. And they are talking about the wedding & Edward asks Bella why she is doing this & they they start making out & Edward is really into it & then Bella stops saying she wants to do it "the right way"  and he asks her whose right way & she says hers & she stops them from basically making love for the first time right there in the meadow.



Jo Anna said:

Emma I couldn't agree more with you about the blood typing scene from Twilight.  I think it was a crucial part to the story and really showed a lot of irony.  I also loved how Edward  carried her to the nurses office, I can't get enough of his chivalry.  Even in the end of Twilight when James has acted her and she is bleeding she referred to the blood.  Oh and remember when Edward said she didn't smell right after the blood transfusions?

 

Can you explain the part you are referring to in Eclipse when he tells her he wants her???  I am lost....  my bad need to read the book again.
Emma Louise said:

Twilight - When they testing which blood type the class was and Bella nearly passed out (They didn't add this to the movie but I think it's a very ironic scene! A vampires gf hating blood! lol)

New Moon - Jacob and Bella get a lot closer in the book than in the film and in the book Bella thinks Edward isn't real and she thinks she has gone crazy or something which I think they should have added to the film.

Eclipse - Alice doesn't 'kidnap' Bella for the sleepover! Also when Jacob kissed Bella in the book she was soo angry which showed how strongly she felt for Edward but in the movie you just saw Edward angry! Also the ending is so much better in the book! They cut out the "i want you bella" stuff out :l

I would of loved to have seen the blood typing and also in eclipse at the end when she goes to see Alice - I wished that would of been in the movie, as well as when Edward said he wanted her right then and there and that he could speak with Carlisle and the use of morphine.  I really hope that they have the part in breaking dawn when she goes home and alice is doing the last fitting on Charlie and bella remembers when the night that she and edward told charlie... I hope that's in the movie.  I wonder if they will include when Bella goes to see J. Jenks... hope so...

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Advertising

FANGIRL WITH US HERE

© 2014    

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...