who is better? edward or jacob?
okay, i dont know whos better, edward or jacob. because if you think about it. both guys will love her. jake could have a kid with her in a safer way. edward could make her immortal. both can protect her. jacob tricked her into kissing him in eclipse and still goes to the fight, edward stays because she wants him to and misses the battle.jacob is just a kid who doesnt know about true love and edward knows how true love goes. who would you choose? and in new moon ed left bella she entered a deep depresion, and jacob was the person to help. and if you can't choose tell me who is better for bella and be on team swizerland!!
Views: 7
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by genesis rivera on -
edward is better because he protects her from everyting and jacob in eclipse(the book) even though bella begged for him to stay with her he tricked her and left her while edward when bella asked him he stayed because he was loyal to her and didn't care what was he missing out on he only cared about bella's feelings so yeah in my opinion edward is better.
-
Permalink Reply by Adina on -
Edward is better!He is more mature,worried(for Bella) and responsible(by Bella).Jacob is her best friend,who loves her but now in the same way.He is a teenager and he don't know how true love is.I know that Jacob is the easy way but sometimes the easy way (which is perfect for some) it's not good enough for your life.And when you have your soul mate you loves you unconditional,how could not choose him like Bella did?
I know that a lot of people changed their team because Edward left Bella in New Moon but nobody thought that he did that for her own good.He never wanted to hurt her.Jacob didn't wanted to do that either but..he did!Plus that Edward wants Bella to be happy,even if she was choosing Jacob.Jake wouldn't do that.
-
Permalink Reply by Last Chance Pack on -
@ genesis rivera you have a point there jacob does trick her and still goes and edward stays. ok good opinion. @adina ok easy way may not be the best way ok i like that. i changed teams when ed left bella but your right not for his own good and some people don't realize that. both opinions so far r great thanks for voicing your opinion.
genesis rivera said:edward is better because he protects her from everyting and jacob in eclipse(the book) even though bella begged for him to stay with her he tricked her and left her while edward when bella asked him he stayed because he was loyal to her and didn't care what was he missing out on he only cared about bella's feelings so yeah in my opinion edward is better.
-
Permalink Reply by ROBSTENrepublik on -
its Edward who is better tha Jacob. Edward loves Bella selflessly. Jacob just thinks of himself. He is always angry at Edward because he thinks Edward do not care for Bella at all. Edward is the right one Bella because he cares too much for her. He never gave up to fight for their relationship. The love of Edward for Bella is indescribable. It is unconditional. It is the sweetest love.I am Pro Edward!
-
Permalink Reply by Renesmee Cullen on -
Team Switzerland
Jake and Daddy are great for her
-
Permalink Reply by Megan davis on -
edward better 4 her coz he hoter than jacob bella and jacob dnt look good together
-
Permalink Reply by Mysterious Jae [Jessa] on -
It doesn't matter who was the right choice for Bella because sometimes the right choice isn't always the best choice. But Bella made that choice before she even realized she had one and she chose Edward in Twilight. So maybe with Jacob; Bella could have lived a normal life and had children. I guess it never really occurs to some that perhaps Bella didn't want that life without Edward. And that maybe whatever life Edward could offer her was what she wanted. "If this is about my soul, take it. I don't want it without you." It's in the movie, but it's basically what she's feeling. She doesn't want a life without Edward, no matter the costs.
I am team Edward because that's who Bella was going to pick all along. It's who she's suppose to be with, forever. Twilight is the story of their love. It was never Jacob. Bella says it best in New Moon, "Don't make me chose. Because it will always be him."
Plus, while it's true Edward might have manipulated Bella he always had the best intentions. He never done it selfishly. But Jacob did. Jacob manipulated Bella for his own benefit and really, who would want to be with someone who thinks that's even remotely okay?
-
Permalink Reply by Last Chance Pack on
-
thank u for ur help i choose team edward
-
Permalink Reply by Aliyah Cullen on -
i am team edward all the way. so he left her but still thats once jacob makes her feel like a bad person bcause she doesnt love him. dont get me rong jacobs cool and wat edward does isnt cool but she ends up with edward and jacob gets renesmee he still gets bella kind of if u think about it
© 2013
Site Created & Designed By:
