i just finished breaking dawn, and i dont really agree. i actually loved the ending but it just made me so sad that it was over and that kate and tanya lost a sister because of a mistake, that i wished i hadn't read it (only to keep myself guessing a little longer) i agree that edward did seem out of character, but what would you do if the love of your existance was dying infront of you??? i sympathize for him.... poor sexy edward. as far as the volturi are concerned im very happy with the outcome. that no one (besides irina) got hurt and that it keeps the outcome happy. (mostly) i love kate and garrett evn though they only have a few lines at the end. but i respect your opinion.