I love both the movies and I agree with Kenzie, both directors did a great job. But I do have a favorite, up until now.
Twilight is my favorite but not because I think the movie is better, not at all... I have ordered the books in my top 4.
4. New Moon
1. Breaking Dawn
I hate the fact that Edward breaks up with Bella... her pain and sorrow... it got to me... i cried while reading New Moon. After finishing all the books I had favorites... and although I love all the books, they can't all take a first place...