Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Tiani Ready on July 29, 2010 at 6:20pm

yes i do i have read all the books as well and i have to agrue with you they show alot more in the books you see the real feelings bella has for jacob and what she has with edward like in eclipse she cant chosse she dont want to hurt jacob she cant see him sad but she dont want to hurt edward but she dont no how to not hurt him without hurting jacob :(

Permalink Reply by aurélie BLACK on August 5, 2010 at 10:11am

yes, i m ok with you Maria Black, i re-read books and seeing movies again and again. I watched eclipse and this is the first time where the movie isn't faithful to the book. i m disappointed. I hope the 4th and last tome (in 2 movies) will be "the breaking dawn" and not a movie for money !

Permalink Reply by elena viviana perez benitez on August 13, 2010 at 4:09pm

I soooooooooooooo agree with you girls! Eclipse left aside so many important details..my guess is that the director assumes that there is not a single person in the world who hasnt read the books ,therefore, many things are taken for granted that everybody knows...like Jake being the real Alfa and the story behind it...for us ,fans there is no missing info since we know the h*** story...but still, so many nice parts hasnt been included...I expected so much...and get little!!!my imagination got carried away and thats an effect that only books can achieve!! see ya!

Permalink Reply by Deja Hammmond on September 29, 2010 at 9:57am

i know they really didnt show alot if the things that were in the book thankfully theyre making 2 parts 2 breaking dawn because if they made only 1 well they would only show half the book beacuse so much stuff is going on breaking dawn :)

aurélie BLACK said:

yes, i m ok with you Maria Black, i re-read books and seeing movies again and again. I watched eclipse and this is the first time where the movie isn't faithful to the book. i m disappointed. I hope the 4th and last tome (in 2 movies) will be "the breaking dawn" and not a movie for money !

Permalink Reply by wolfgirl40 on October 4, 2010 at 12:42pm

Tiani Ready said:

yes i do i have read all the books as well and i have to agrue with you they show alot more in the books you see the real feelings bella has for jacob and what she has with edward like in eclipse she cant chosse she dont want to hurt jacob she cant see him sad but she dont want to hurt edward but she dont no how to not hurt him without hurting jacob :(

I agree with you that the Edward Bella angle does get more attention than the rest of her loyalties. even her relationship with her father. Buth that is just the choice of the screen writer as to which relationships will make the movie more popular, and better for box office. Thankfully we get the same screenwriter for all 4 movies so they have the same "viewpoint".