Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by TwilightTrinity AKA Shaun on July 23, 2010 at 11:55am

I agree.Bree had a pure heart and she was decieved.She didnt deserve to be killed.I think if she had lived,the Cullens would have taught her their morals and values and to respect human life as they do.She truly was a victim.

Permalink Reply by Ace Black on July 23, 2010 at 4:01pm

Well, in the book "The short second life of bree tanner" it makes more sense why she died, and besieds she had not alot of reasons to live for (It explains why in the book)

Permalink Reply by TwilightTrinity AKA Shaun on July 23, 2010 at 4:34pm

Still,she should have had some kind of a trial or something.Bree was being manipulated because she was a newborn that didnt know anything.The Volturi don't consider that and they dont believe in fair trial. They just believe in guilt and punishment.She only did what she was told and she was never taught to control her thirst. She is a victim any way you look at it.

Permalink Reply by TwilightTrinity AKA Shaun on July 23, 2010 at 4:37pm

If they were willing to bend the rules for Bella,they should have been willing to bend the rules for a poor newborn who didnt know any better

ShaunTwilightTrinity said:

Still,she should have had some kind of a trial or something.Bree was being manipulated because she was a newborn that didnt know anything.The Volturi don't consider that and they dont believe in fair trial. They just believe in guilt and punishment.She only did what she was told and she was never taught to control her thirst. She is a victim any way you look at it.

Permalink Reply by Carmen Rohde on July 23, 2010 at 5:59pm

I agree that Bree should have been kept alive, but in novella she dies. I think that the Volturi killed her because they might have thought that Bree new too much...She was actually very controlled unlike the other newborns that Riley was training. She actually figured out what was going on...she figured out that Edward could read her mind and she warned the Cullens. She would have been an asset to the Cullen family. They were willing to bend the rules for Bella because they know that Bella will have special powers.

Permalink Reply by Julia Kahi on July 25, 2010 at 11:13am

I haven't read the book yet (the short second life of bree tanner) but I kind of agree in some ways, that she should have been kept alive and given a chance to live, but what can you do, that's how the book was written.

Permalink Reply by Alba g.malmbom on July 25, 2010 at 11:55am

i think that stephenie keept bree alive becos she wanted the volturie to show that they were serious about bella and that Stephenie wanted to show how crule they realy are...