Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Luna Bella Waite on July 3, 2010 at 12:31am

OMG Twilight is my favorite in the series but I have to say I do enjoy Edward's perspective just slightly more than Bella's; Edward is so much more deep and expressive(and way more adorable than you know through Bella) and insightful than Bella which is the kind of writing I love to both read and write.

I want so badly for Midnight Sun to be finished.

Permalink Reply by M Reyes on July 3, 2010 at 5:16am

I love MS and I agree! EC's point of view is slightly better expressed than Bella's. I know Stephenie has mentioned that she's all vampired out. But, I would love nothing more than to read the WHOLE saga in EC's point of view. (I even thought it would really be something to have Jacob's point of view as well).

Permalink Reply by juliana caicedo on July 3, 2010 at 10:01am

Totally agree , i mean, to see how edward thinks through all the series would be like really awesome, but SM said she'd only write twilight in edwards point of view (midnight sun), so its too bad. anyway, I'd love to see what edward thinks while bellas pregnancy i mean when he hears renesmee and tell bella that she loves her that would be totally amazing... its a shame to know that we'll never be able to read that part...

Michelle Reyes said:

I love MS and I agree! EC's point of view is slightly better expressed than Bella's. I know Stephenie has mentioned that she's all vampired out. But, I would love nothing more than to read the WHOLE saga in EC's point of view. (I even thought it would really be something to have Jacob's point of view as well).

Permalink Reply by Luna Bella Waite on July 3, 2010 at 12:16pm

juliana caicedo said:

Totally agree , i mean, to see how edward thinks through all the series would be like really awesome, but SM said she'd only write twilight in edwards point of view (midnight sun), so its too bad. anyway, I'd love to see what edward thinks while bellas pregnancy i mean when he hears renesmee and tell bella that she loves her that would be totally amazing... its a shame to know that we'll never be able to read that part...
.

I completely agree I would have preferred Edward's POV to Jacob's in BD, a main reason I hate BD. I would have loved to know what his thoughts had been when he heard the fetus for the first time, saw the baby, saw Bella as a vampire, things like that.

And even in Eclipse Edward's thoughts would have been very interesting.

Permalink Reply by juliana caicedo on July 3, 2010 at 12:19pm

haha you want is the h*** saga in edwards point of view!!! and that'd be great!!!!! =D

Bella Cullen-Pattinson said:

juliana caicedo said:

Totally agree , i mean, to see how edward thinks through all the series would be like really awesome, but SM said she'd only write twilight in edwards point of view (midnight sun), so its too bad. anyway, I'd love to see what edward thinks while bellas pregnancy i mean when he hears renesmee and tell bella that she loves her that would be totally amazing... its a shame to know that we'll never be able to read that part...

Michelle Reyes said:

I love MS and I agree! EC's point of view is slightly better expressed than Bella's. I know Stephenie has mentioned that she's all vampired out. But, I would love nothing more than to read the WHOLE saga in EC's point of view. (I even thought it would really be something to have Jacob's point of view as well).

I completely agree I would have preferred Edward's POV to Jacob's in BD, a main reason I hate BD. I would have loved to know what his thoughts had been when he heard the fetus for the first time, saw the baby, saw Bella as a vampire, things like that.

And even in Eclipse Edward's thoughts would have been very interesting.

Permalink Reply by Luna Bella Waite on July 3, 2010 at 12:20pm

NM would have been difficult though since he's away from Bella, but I would still read it, it's my Edward! <3

Permalink Reply by Dominique Rougeau on July 15, 2010 at 1:37pm

Twilight is my 2nd favorite book in the saga... but after reading the 1st half of Midnight Sun, that looks even BETTER than Twilight! And I 110 percent agree w/ all of you guys. It was a lot more intresting to read Edward's p.o.v. of Twilght! :D

Permalink Reply by wig4rob on July 15, 2010 at 11:47pm

I was blown away by MS. I do think its the best, Edward's POV is amazing and for me, made Twilight even better when I understood him more.