Discussion Post: You're on Survivor with the Cullens, who do you vote off the island?

With limited news and information coming out of Baton Rouge from the Breaking Dawn set, we thought lwt's play a game.

If you were on a deserted island with the Cullen family who would you vote off first and why??

The TwiFans' admins weight in....

Alison says: Umm ALICE! I couldn't have her knowing my actions before I did them & Edward I can drown out when I need to with the alphabet.

Kim says: If I'm voting personality I vote Rosalie just because I'm not a fan of hers over all. If I'm voting strategy it's more difficult because you've got Edward & Alice with the special powers or Emmett who's really strong, then there's Jasper who was a soldier & used to rough conditions. Scratch Edward, I would never vote him off & would hope the final 2 would be me & him alone! Bwhaha!

Missy says: If I had to kick a Cullen off the Island, it would probably be Alice. She would be the biggest threat, since she can see the future and could tell what all the challenges are ahead of time. I don't care about Edward because whatever is in my head, I'll tell him to his face :P

Ms Monkey Man says: I know I'm gonna be killed for this, but I'd vote off Edward. Because I wouldn't want him to know my next move before everyone else. Next to go would be Alice for the same reason. Then Jasper. After that, it's every man for themselves. May the best one win.

Samuel says: Jasper - because he'd either lose it and bite me (and not be able to stop) or he'd be far too good at discerning people's true intentions. Also, I wouldn't be able to trust my instincts and strategize appropriately.

What do you think???

Tags: cullen, game, member, style, survivor

Comment by Gabrielle on January 31, 2011 at 6:55pm: I agree with voting off Rosalie. I just personally do not like her character. Then I would keep voting till I was all alone with Edward(: I'm 15, but hey, he is 17, right? Close enough.

Comment by Susan Ann West on January 31, 2011 at 7:02pm: Jasper, because he's more likely to kill me.

Comment by i♥RobertP♥ on January 31, 2011 at 7:08pm: totally agree with you Susan. and you too Gab i'll keep voting them off until i end up with Edward! n_n

Comment by Vampire Bella Marie Cullen on January 31, 2011 at 7:43pm: none cuz i love the cullens but i would vote off everyone but Edward or Carisle. Edward cuz he is a sexy beast and he would leave bella for me. Carisle cuz he could turn me into a Vampire without killing me and then I would be with Edward either way cuz lets say Bella isnt with us anymore. Edward is all mine. yayayayayyayayayayay

Comment by sue akers on January 31, 2011 at 8:17pm: Sorry Jasper, u gotta go first! With his inability to be "in control" around human blood would be the greatest threat for me! I'm basically a clutz and would be spilling my cells all over the island within a matter of minutes. Then he has the wjole mood control thing goin' on. While this is a very cpol power, and I would give my right lung to have this gift, I perceive it to be the greatest threat. Next would be Rose. My heart aches for her and her longing for a normal human life, she is ultimately a b****! I figure there can only be one on the island and I will be claiming that position. LOL! Next would be a toss up between Bella a d Alice. Bella became a very strong willed and in control "newborn". HUGE THREAT! sweet Alice...the threat there is obvious. Then i'd just pick em off until I was left withEmmitt. and Edward. What an ending to a beautiful dream. Need I say more?

Comment by Taylor Marie Bannon on January 31, 2011 at 8:32pm: i would vote myself off because i love them all lol but if i HAD to choose i would pick Rosalie screw stratagey and strength, if shes there, (in my opinion) she would just get on my nerves i like her though lol:)

Comment by Terri Morales on January 31, 2011 at 8:40pm: Rosalie, no doubt!

Comment by Dana on January 31, 2011 at 8:44pm: I would keep Carlisle so he could save me if I was sick or injured, I'd form an alliance with him. Keep Rosalie too-since everyone hates her and I'd win in a vote. Love Edward and Alice-but they'd be the first to go due to mind reading and fortune telling ;).

Comment by BB Cullen on January 31, 2011 at 8:49pm: I love all the Cullens!! but I gotta agree to vote of Rosalie cause she doesn't really have any special power or anything like that like....
Edward - Mind Reading
Bella - Shield
Emmet - Strenght
Alice - Future Seeing
Jasper - Mood Control
Carlilse and Esme - The Peacemakers
and Whats Roslaie got Looks?? lol
I love all Cullens though!!
(sorry for the long explination if it annoys anyone I was bored!! lol)

Comment by Laurie Cullen Whitlock on January 31, 2011 at 8:56pm: I am so totally voting off Alice that little pixie will know everyone ideas before the challenges then Edward would be second because of the mind reading unless he couldn't hear me that is, third would be Rose, then Esme, Carlisle, Em which would leave me and Jazz perfect lol ;)