Discussion Post: You're on Survivor with the Cullens, who do you vote off the island?


With limited news and information coming out of Baton Rouge from the Breaking Dawn set, we thought lwt's play a game.


If you were on a deserted island with the Cullen family who would you vote off first and why??


The TwiFans' admins weight in....



Alison says:  Umm ALICE! I couldn't have her knowing my actions before I did them & Edward I can drown out when I need to with the alphabet.


Kim says:  If I'm voting personality I vote Rosalie just because I'm not a fan of hers over all. If I'm voting strategy it's more difficult because you've got Edward & Alice with the special powers or Emmett who's really strong, then there's Jasper who was a soldier & used to rough conditions. Scratch Edward, I would never vote him off & would hope the final 2 would be me & him alone! Bwhaha!

Missy says:  If I had to kick a Cullen off the Island, it would probably be Alice. She would be the biggest threat, since she can see the future and could tell what all the challenges are ahead of time. I don't care about Edward because whatever is in my head, I'll tell him to his face :P


Ms Monkey Man says:  I know I'm gonna be killed for this, but I'd vote off Edward. Because I wouldn't want him to know my next move before everyone else. Next to go would be Alice for the same reason. Then Jasper. After that, it's every man for themselves. May the best one win.


Samuel says:   Jasper - because he'd either lose it and bite me (and not be able to stop) or he'd be far too good at discerning people's true intentions.  Also, I wouldn't be able to trust my instincts and strategize appropriately.


What do you think???

Views: 37

Comment by Rachel Hernandez on January 31, 2011 at 9:02pm
I'd get rid of Alice cause she would know how to find the immunity idol. lol. Then Rosalie cause I can bet she wouldn't be much fun. Then Jasper cause he could mess with my emotions.
Comment by princesskae on January 31, 2011 at 9:09pm

i would vote off alice first.. i'm sorry but you can't control your gift.. and that's cheating..

then edward.. mindreader.. really not fair..

then jazz.. then emmett.. .. carlisle... then esme


i would keep rosalie.. because everyone hates her.. they would kick her way before me.. lol ...




Comment by Jacqueline Valenzuela on January 31, 2011 at 10:13pm



i would vote off alice (i love her dearly, but she's got to go for the same reasons listed already), then jasper (so alice doesn't come after me cuz i kept her man longer. lol), emmett (love him too, but he's a threat), rosalie (cuz she's too beautiful to be on an island anway...plus she's kinda a b&3@* :P), then bella...wait does bella count? well she does to me anyway (i don't want compitition for edward hahaha), esme (love her too, but hey she made it this far and i'll miss her cooking too lol), carlisle (i saved him for the final 3 cuz i'm accident proned and i needed him lol), and finally i would agree with kim...keep edward till the end....even then i wouldn't let go. we just may create our own isle esmee. lmao. :D

Comment by Carlisles Sarah Ann-Marie Cullen on January 31, 2011 at 10:21pm

I love all the Cullens! But I gotta too agree (with you Gabrielle) to vote of Rosalie because personally I do not like her character. Maybe next Alice and then Jasper and so on. 


Then I would too keep voting until I'm all alone with Edward! :D Hahaha! :D ;)

Comment by Cynthia Mullen on January 31, 2011 at 10:35pm
i'd say alice. as much as i love her, she'd know what i was going to do so she'd win anyway, the others i could easily get passed.
Comment by Twilighter76 on February 1, 2011 at 12:13am
voting Jasper off SORRY !
Comment by WillyNilly on February 1, 2011 at 12:49am
Comment by JoS on February 1, 2011 at 2:52am
i would vote off Rosalie first
Comment by Cynthia Mullen on February 1, 2011 at 4:08am
see you guys are just missing out. alice would beat you. she would win. vote her offbefore she knows you will and before she votes you off. duh!!!
Comment by jade barnes on February 1, 2011 at 5:47am
i would vote rosalie off, i dont have anything against her but she seems like she would be just a negative vibe the entire time!


You need to be a member of TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite to add comments!

Join TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite



© 2016       Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...