Does Edward look similar in Eclipse to Twilight???

I think Edward looks very similar in styling in Eclipse to Twilight and much better than New Moon he looks young and fresh in his T shirt i love this look on him, what do you guys think??

Source is me i screencapped Twilight and the eclipse pic is from the new boardgame

Tags: Edward

Comment by Carmina Cullen on May 24, 2010 at 7:11am: I liked his hair in Twilight, then at the present... Eclipse (much better). 'coz on New Moon, he looks kind'a depressed. *role requirement, indeed.* :)

Comment by Samantha Cullen on May 24, 2010 at 7:41am: so much better then new moon!!!!!

Comment by Lucy_is_a_twilight_obsessive on May 24, 2010 at 9:22am: love love love

Comment by Marina Flourentzou on May 24, 2010 at 9:30am: Yeahhh!! NOW he looks 17..Not like new moon...
Go teeam edwardd <3333

Comment by tet_d on May 25, 2010 at 6:08am: He doesn't look anything like Edward in New Moon (read: young and fresh, as you put it) because he was stuck up with that formal wear since bella's birthday til at volturi's lair. Even at last scene he still wears formal (except that first few scenes at school). Good to know he's wearing those normal shirts again - i always love to see Rob's arms... lol

Comment by Kim Cartmill on May 25, 2010 at 9:58am: I love him in both! I have to say I like the feel of Twilight and Eclipse better than New Moon! But New moon was a better movie than Twilight because it stuck more to the book! I love Robert in these movies no matter, he will make the character hot either way!