This is my own attempt at the evolution of the cullens and jacob. ive tried to pic some of the best pics available from many stills and screencaps from each movie.
Here is my own personal verdict:
Bella - Twilight
Edward - Twilight (looks the correct age) or Eclipse (looks hot)
Esme - Twilight is most like the description i feel
Carlisle - Twilight (the wig in the others looks old)
Alice - Twilight (pixie look is closest to the book)
Jasper - I kinda like Twilight for that
Rosalie - New Moon (the wig actually looks better than the died hair in Twilight)
Emmett - He looked softer in Twilight than New Moon and his fringe is longer in Eclipse i'll stick with Twilight
Jacob - He looks hot whatever Liking Eclipse for this though
So overall I think that Catherine Hardwicks designers did a better job in Twilight when you look at each one, again this is just my personal view and i'd love to hear yours, remember to respect each others comments and if you use this picture please credit me for the work. thanks.