If you had a chance,Who would you have picked for the Twilight cast?

I got into Twilight a little late. I had only finished the first book when the movie came out. So I didnt have enough time to have and objective opinion on who I would have liked to see play each of the charactors. In retrospect, my choices for Edward and Bella were totally different. But,I've gotten used to Rob Pattinson and Kristen Stewart. I'm not sure who I would have chosen for Bella.All I know is that Kristen Stewart is too hostile and moody to be Bella. Bella was shy and withdrawn in the book,but she wasnt hostile the way Kristen Stewart protrayed her(It seems like shes that way in every movie she makes--like thats the only charactor she knows how to play).I hadnt even heard of Rob Pattinson when Twilight came out,But I had 2 other actors in mind for Edward- Hayden Christiansen or James Franco.(James Franco has that twisted smile that Edward is described having in the book.) But,like I said,I've gotten used to him as Edward and now I cant see anyone else playing him. As for the rest of the Cullen's,I think they were cast perfectly. What do you all think?

Comment by Kelsey Gilman on January 4, 2011 at 1:02pm: I would have chosen zac effron for edward...he is way more dreamy. As for Bella, i would never have chosen Kristen. Idk if anyone has seen the movie Thirteen (nikki acted/directed the movie. her co-actress' name in the movie was Tracy. goes out with marilyn manson) anyways, i think she would have made an awesome Bella.

Comment by TwilightTrinity AKA Shaun on January 4, 2011 at 1:03pm: I totally agree

Comment by TwilightTrinity AKA Shaun on January 15, 2011 at 9:43pm: Actually,I would have liked to see Ellen Page take on the roll of Bella.I know shes older.But I mean if Rob can pull off being 17, she can pull off being 18. And she pulled off being 16 in Juno. Besides, shes a much better dramatic actress. When Kristen Stewart does it, she tries too hard and still doesnt pull it off in my opinion. When shes dramatic, she makes it look fake. Although I dont know how she would feel with Ellen Page having these hot love scenes with Rob. But, other, married/engaged actresses can deal with it,she should be able to.

Comment by TwilightTrinity AKA Shaun on January 15, 2011 at 9:48pm: oh and she also has that "not too plain, but TOO pretty" look.Not that shes not pretty.But,shes not like "supermodel" pretty

Comment by Isabella Cullen on March 13, 2011 at 11:04pm: Personally, I think Edward, Bella and The Cullens were cast perfectly, but I am pissed that they cast Mackenzie Foy as Renesmee. Renesmee is the size of a five year old not ten year old. I don't know if any one will agree with me on this or not, but that is just my opinion. Gemma Devine would have been a perfect choice for Renesmee.