It's moments like these I wonder: What the F%&!K are the Critics thinking?!?


So, it's 4AM here in Southern California.. just got home from watching New Moon at a midnight showing. I'm literally in awe! The movie blew me, and literally everyone in the theater out of the water... we all cheered, screamed, laughed, and cried.
This movie makes me think, how the hell did Chris Weitz NOT direct Twilight? Would have saved us some good time and ... well some not happy fans.

Well, I get home right now, its late.. I get curious to see what the critics have to say. Though I'm thinking, oh yea this is going to get pretty good reviews.. nope. This is what they had to say... I can't even believe there is not one good remark about the movie, the graphics, the beauty, the music... how it fit so perfect. Somehow critics just dont get it.

I need EVERYONE on Twifans feedback on this situation. This seems pretty ridiculous!
Do you agree with the critics? Disagree? Why? If you were the Critic, and thinking outside of the "FANS" perspective, what would you rate it? A B C? D??

Views: 32

Tags: Moon, New, Review

Comment by Heather Begley on November 20, 2009 at 9:35am
Well this is all i have to say about it if the critics hated it then I know i will love it, I was unable to get tickets in the small town i live in so i have to waite tell tom. to see it. but i have found in the past that anything that the critics thought was the greatest movie of the year. I hated, and how often does that happen anyway i think they get payed to be sour about every thing anyways. go twilight (new moon) we are behind you.and you just wait and see the critics will have to eat there words when this movie makes millions
Comment by POTO on November 20, 2009 at 9:39am
I ABSOLUTELY DISAGREE WITH THESE CRITICS! Best thing to do is remember that the proof is in the pudding here and let's see what the box office says. That and the fans who are paying good money to see the movie are the true indicator of how good the movie is. Also remember that the word critic and criticize are pretty much the same and that is their job.

Now outside the box I would give it a B+ or A- only for some of the music. While it was beautiful I thought there was a little too much schmoozy music but it was well placed.

I sincerely hope that Summit ignores the reviews and listens to their and the movies fans when making the deision on Breaking Dawn!
Comment by Mandee | Ѽ |owns it!!! on November 20, 2009 at 9:40am
i loved the movie but i agree that in parts it did drag, and i think we enjoy it so much more because we are fans of the book, so we knew what to expect and were just waiting for it, i will admitt when twilight came out i hated it, it seemed so stupid and childish but ive watched it about 1000 times now and i love it.
Comment by Kaitlyn Morrill on November 20, 2009 at 9:43am
The critics probably aren't hard core fans like the rest of us and are looking at it from the cynical, snoby standpoint of someone tryign to make the papers. If the movie was reviewed by fans, esp. from this site, the reviews would be the best in history. I saw it last night too at midnight in Maryland, and these reviews are horse poop.
Comment by SickMasochisticLion on November 20, 2009 at 9:51am
OK, first off, I am a man who loves the books, has read them three times, has watched Twilight probably over 700 bazillion times, has a Bella screen saver, and got all my friends and family into the books as well. I teach 5th grade and started reading them to see what my students were reading. Now, here I am, blurry eyed because I took my wife and our 4 best friends to the opening last night, and WE ALL F'IN' LOVED IT!!!!!!!!! The critics are morons and idiots, and I hope they soon come to know it!!! Chris Weitz just raised the bar!!
Comment by Gia on November 20, 2009 at 10:05am
who gives a s*** on your opinions? we love the movies. we love the books. 10 stupid without-brain critics can't change the mind of milions of fans. we didn't even saw eclipse and we are sure that is going to be great. i didn't even saw new moon yet. but for the love of what's holy i swear that if someone tries to say something bad about it he will not be able to speak after. like i said we are milions of twifans... we are the important ones. we are the ones who really can say if the movie is good or not. since we are so many that must be something.
Comment by Deanna Couture on November 20, 2009 at 10:09am
Maybe the critics were only focused on the wigs on Alice and Rosalie, they were pretty bad, but the timing, storyline, special effects and movie in general were A W E S O M E !!!!!!!!!! I was amazed that they crammed the entire book in such a short period of time, I had expected to see major parts cut out, but nope, a little re-arranging was great. I laughed, I cried, and Never Once did ever hear anybody say they didn't like it when they were leaving. OK but you most must agree the scene from Alice's vision was a little hokey, everyone in my theater cracked up
Comment by Mrs Cullen on November 20, 2009 at 10:15am
i think the film was insanely amazing ok it dint flow to well looked like some of the scenes had been cut but thats what you get when you try put a book into a film!!! it was amazing regardless the special effect the sparkling wow it was crazy i loved it omg the critics dont get anything there KNOBS!!! END OF!!!
Comment by Frances on November 20, 2009 at 10:37am
Who cares what the critics say!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The fans love it..and that is ALL that matters!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Comment by Miranda Jones on November 20, 2009 at 10:53am
I do not agree with the critics at all! I LOVED this movie, I am a HUGE fan, and everyone else I know who has seen it loved it also! But this is why they call them critics, because they CRITICIZE everything! Its not there opinion that matters! Its what the FANS THINK and anyone who is a fan will love this movie. The actors and director did an amazing job! I will be back to watch this one over and over!

Comment

You need to be a member of TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite to add comments!

Join TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite

Advertising

FANGIRL WITH US HERE

© 2014    

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...