It's hard for me to rate the Twilight Saga in any kind of preference order, as each one is unique and evokes a range of great emotions. It's only until I reached approx 3/4 of the way through Breaking Dawn that another emotion / feeling set in.......The emotion I felt was disbelief and disappointment ! ......and it happened around about the time that Jacob suddenly decided to phase in front of Charlie and let the cat (or Wolf) out of the bag with absolutely NO repercussions from Charlie. Was it just me or did anyone else find his reaction to the whole Werewolf / Bella / Vampire on a 'need to know basis' ridiculous and completely out of character for Charlie Swan - Head of Police in Forks who had been conducting a manhunt for weeks looking for some 'animal' who had attacked his friends and residences of Forks ?!?
I think this is the only weak area of the whole Twilight Saga, and although its only a minor point I think it's definately a flaw in the story/saga. I can't help thinking that this is NOT the reaction of a police officer / Bella's father and just maybe the whole 'reveal' to Charlie was a little rushed and conveniently easy.
If it wasn't for that, I think Breaking Dawn and the unfinished Midnight Sun are currently my favourites !!