- "There's no religion that could save me"
That's something Edward might say, as the topic of souls is seemingly always on his mind.
- "Your daddy can't even look me in the eye"
That one's obviously on the Edward side of the spectrum. Charlie loves Jacob, so that wouldn't be applicable to him.
- "I'll pick up these broken pieces 'til I'm bleeding"
These words sound more like Jacob, since Edward can't bleed . . . obviously. Unless it's meant to be a bit ironic, which is also possible.
This is the line, I think, that's gotten people thinking this is a Jacob-esque song. It's very reminiscent of the moment when Jacob tells Bella (during their wedding dance) that he thought he'd get used to telling her goodbye.
- "Cause there'll be no more sunlight if I lose you, baby"
Very neutral line, right? On the one hand, you could say that this is Edward-ish, since he's the type who would credit Bella for sunlight returning to his life in the first place; hence, if he lost her, it would be gone. On the other, it could totally be Jacob's line of thinking.