I found this great post by make_me_irish and I had to share after reading the commentary.
I thought Rob was spot on to exactly what we were all really thinking. Go ROB.
Rob: I just don't get your decision making process to leave here. I didn't even understand it at the time, I was just like "God, I'd break up with you immediately". It's like "Please, please don't leave me. Don't leave me, please." And she's like "Shut up! I'm gonna go with this guy who wants to cheat- who wants to sleep with me." I said the wrong word for kids: "He wants to hold my hand".
Kristen: Shut up. I mean, the whole thing is like...that's the whole first argument that they have in the beginning is, you know, she's allowed to have other relationships.
Rob: WHY? No she's not allowed to have other relationships. If I ever saw my girlfriend go round to this bunch of guys house with their little shirts- with their bellies out, and their fake tan, nipples, and their iron-on tattoos....
Kristen: Edward is just a little bit more mature than you.
Rob: Edward's in a lose/lose situation in this movie. Kind of.
Kristen: How is he in a lose/lose situation?
Rob: 'Cause like, you know, you pushed him around.
Kristen: What? You are such- you always wanna play the victim.
Rob: I was working til 5:30 in the morning, I can't think what I'm talking about.
Rob: He is a victim. He's really, really victimized.
Rob: Again, Taylor did wanna be here but he has better stuff to do. He's working out right now.
Kristen: Everyone's always questioning her, you know?
Rob: Yeah, but Jesus, so would I. Apart from Edward. Edward's not, he's just like "listen, this is how it is".
Kristen: He's not? Edward's not questioning? Are you kidding me?
Rob: He doesn't question her. He just tells her how it is.
Kristen: Exactly, which is basically always the opposite. He completely disregards any of her feelings.
Rob: Yeah, but obviously you would. Why should he listen to some girl say she likes some other guy?
See the rest of the post here.