Was Rob's Eclipse commentary exactly what "Team Edward" girls were thinking!?!

I found this great post by make_me_irish and I had to share after reading the commentary.

I thought Rob was spot on to exactly what we were all really thinking.  Go ROB.

Rob: I just don't get your decision making process to leave here. I didn't even understand it at the time, I was just like "God, I'd break up with you immediately". It's like "Please, please don't leave me. Don't leave me, please." And she's like "Shut up! I'm gonna go with this guy who wants to cheat- who wants to sleep with me." I said the wrong word for kids: "He wants to hold my hand".
Kristen: Shut up. I mean, the whole thing is like...that's the whole first argument that they have in the beginning is, you know, she's allowed to have other relationships.
Rob: WHY? No she's not allowed to have other relationships. If I ever saw my girlfriend go round to this bunch of guys house with their little shirts- with their bellies out, and their fake tan, nipples, and their iron-on tattoos....
Kristen: Edward is just a little bit more mature than you.
Rob: Mature?
Kristen: Yep.
Rob: Nah.

Kristen: This is when he explains imprinting, or tries to explain imprinting.
Rob: Oh man! That's gonna be the best scene in Breaking Dawn. I cannot wait. Oh my God.

Rob: Edward's in a lose/lose situation in this movie. Kind of.
Kristen: How is he in a lose/lose situation?
Rob: 'Cause like, you know, you pushed him around.
Kristen: What? You are such- you always wanna play the victim.
Rob: I was working til 5:30 in the morning, I can't think what I'm talking about.
Rob: He is a victim. He's really, really victimized.

Rob: Again, Taylor did wanna be here but he has better stuff to do. He's working out right now.

Kristen: Everyone's always questioning her, you know?
Rob: Yeah, but Jesus, so would I. Apart from Edward. Edward's not, he's just like "listen, this is how it is".
Kristen: He's not? Edward's not questioning? Are you kidding me?
Rob: He doesn't question her. He just tells her how it is.
Kristen: Exactly, which is basically always the opposite. He completely disregards any of her feelings.
Rob: Yeah, but obviously you would. Why should he listen to some girl say she likes some other guy?

[Jacob: she's not sure what she wants] Rob: Yes she is!


See the rest of the post here.

Views: 199

Comment by Sarah Anaya aka Cookie Monster ! on December 16, 2010 at 6:59am

LOL omg i love this so much .. rob is just too damn funny .. to top it off its like me and him were thinking the same things during these scenes ... i love the jab at taylor " again taylor would have loved to be here but he had better things to do .. he's working out right now " lol



aaww i love you rob so much <33

Comment by Natalia Rose Cullen on December 16, 2010 at 7:15am

and I don't have it on dvd and i'm so furios about it. i have to save some money and buy blu-ray player...

Comment by Renesmee13 on December 16, 2010 at 7:17am

Love him :) So sweet... But I dont know why but sometimes I have got a feeling that Kristen prefers much Jacob than Edward... Just dont know why... Maybe she talks like that...

Comment by Angi2a on December 16, 2010 at 11:37am

I loved it as well and like Sabrina said they really know their character! When I was listenning to them I couldn't stop thinking how close they are!! so cute!

Comment by Alice Jasper Bella Cullen on December 16, 2010 at 12:04pm

I love the part where he says "shut up im gona go with this guy.." ect when he said in an english acent shut up i was laughing for hours!!

Comment by Aimzers on December 16, 2010 at 1:22pm

the one that got me was when the tent scene was on and Rob says "god, I really hate Jacob" and Kristen asked why or something and he goes on to talk about how hes so cocky etc... that made me laugh bc thats my thinking for sure lol

Comment by Aimzers on December 16, 2010 at 1:23pm

Natalia Rose Cullen - you dont need the blu ray... you can buy special edition and it has commentary

Comment by debbie dixon on December 16, 2010 at 2:10pm

Its not Slade's fault because New Moon was Jacob, Jacob,Jacob.I really think Kristen knows who Bella is more than Rob. Edward plays the victim and lets his guilt about leaving her in New Moon cloud things. Edward broods and blames himself for things a lot even in BD until Nessie is born. What I didn't like was that Bella doesn't leave with Jacob in the book until later but in the movie she does.This is just my opinion.

Comment by Pennybug Cullen on December 16, 2010 at 2:17pm

Yet another reason to love Rob!! I agree w/everything he said! Especially the riding off w/Jacob part & the she doesn't know what she wants line?! Are you kidding me?! Bella knows EXACTLY what she wants. She even told him in the part right before he assaulted/tried to kiss her!!

Comment by Sasha A. on December 16, 2010 at 2:28pm

Oh Come on Kristen! Edward disregards her feelings??? He had to deal with all her crap about wanting to be with other guy while she had a boyfriend who loved her and just wanted to protect her and you say he just disregarded her feelings???? I don't like to think of Edward as a victim but in this movie he was! =( My poor Edward just wanted the love of his life to be happy, he didn't question her, some can say that on some level she cheated on him but he accepted all that because he LOVES her sooo much!


You need to be a member of TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite to add comments!

Join TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite



© 2016       Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...