Which is your favorite Edward ~ How should he look in Breaking Dawn?

Through the last three Twilight films, we have seen our precious Edward change a bit. He started off as very young and angelic looking, then he went more to the older more tormented Edward in New Moon, and I feel he looked the oldest and yet demure in Eclipse. While in the real world we can not stop time and ageing as Stephanie Meyer's has in her books, I am curious as to what Edward will look like in Breaking Dawn. While I favor the Twilight Edward out of the 3, because that is what I imagined from the books, I did kind of take to the Eclipse Edward more *dominant look*… A mix between the Twilight and Eclipse Edward would be hot in my opinion.

So out of Twilight Edward, New Moon Edward and Eclipse Edward, which on do you favor the most? Your thoughts on how Edward should look in Breaking Dawn?

Pic collage by Aidinslevel

Tags: Breaking, Dawn?, Edward, How, Which, favorite, he, in, is, look, More…should, your, ~

Comment by Amy on August 31, 2010 at 11:08am: New Moon Edward for sure! He looks so clean cut and sexy!

Comment by Amelle on August 31, 2010 at 11:10am: I loooooooooved the eclipse look ,
new moon wasn't that great :s

twilight was good but the best stil is eclipse ;D

Comment by Jennifer Lentz on August 31, 2010 at 11:12am: I'll take all of the above. But I think Eclipse is my favorite

Comment by Marianne on August 31, 2010 at 11:34am: I LOVE Robert Pattinson regardless, but my favorite Edward was in TWILIGHT. When he made his entrance in the cafeteria...he ABSOLUTELY PERSONIFIED Edward from the books!

In the books he is described as forever 17, beautifully perfect with copper colored hair and practically Greek God -like. Edward jumped off the pages and became real when Robert entered that cafeteria.

I understand Rob didn't particularly like his "look" in TWILIGHT, but it was a faithful interpretation by Catherine Hardwicke - she nailed it! In NEW MOON, Rob and director Chris Weitz changed Edward's look to look more like that of a High School senior, but in my opinion, he looked too old - not a boy of 17 but a young man of 22.

Eclipse's Edward was much better, the clothes and hair and make-up, but he still did not look like a boy of 17, still a bit too mature looking. Although in all honestly, it would be hard to imagine Edward looking like he did in TWILIGHT holding a baby!

I'm thinking a combination of the looks would be best :)

Comment by Edward Lover 87 on August 31, 2010 at 11:44am: I can't choose, that's like asking me the pick my favorite friend. I think Robert as Edward has Looked gorgeous in all the movies, and I sure he will look just at Gorgeous as he always dose I think he keeps getting more and more Gorgeous in each Movie. Go Team Edward!!!!!

Comment by Veronique on August 31, 2010 at 12:02pm: Only Twilight Edward! I don't like Edward in NW or Eclipse, becouse he looks old and tired... not so sexy...

Comment by ivy on August 31, 2010 at 12:07pm: Twilight!

Comment by Maggie on August 31, 2010 at 12:08pm: HAIR of TWILIGHT ; EYES of NEW MOON; ATTITUDE from eclipse anddd voila perfect BD edward lol

Comment by Elle on August 31, 2010 at 12:11pm: I'm between eclipse edward and twilight ... but idk i think he looks better ( hotter) in eclipse!!!!

Comment by Topaz Girl on August 31, 2010 at 12:16pm: Edward in the truck, Edward in the rain, Bella's fingers in Edward's hair... tortured eyes, adoring eyes, distracted expression, fake sleeping, or watching Bella sleep...Edward any way is EDWARD!