this is a follow- up to my blog about how much twilight sucks.

yes, i am responding!!! many of you thought i wouldnt- yeah ok. like im gonna let this go!
some one called me an attention seeker with too much free time- yup thats pretty much true. i was just looking for someone to debate with, and you guys pretty much answered my call! lol. and i do have alot of free time.....

ok. so some of you said that im saying you cant like 2 book series @ once. YOU CAN! im just saying harry potter is better- but if you dont think so whatever!!!! im jsut insulted that you ppl started saying that twilight is the new harry potter, and how harry potter is a kids book when you havnt even read it!!!! i read twilight and ill give meyer props for the 1st one. good, fun read. but the last 3 books are just puke, puke, puke. theyre innapropriate, and now youre all probably saying "see, youre some kid and you just read kid books. im not saying that but only a book thats written for all ages is gonna last! harry potter is a legend and it owns the literature world. twilight will fade somday. wake up! yup, robert pattinson is cute but EDWARD ISNT REAL!! wow you people.......

so if anyone wants to debate with me, im free!! lol
peace~love~lightning bolt scars

Views: 25

Comment by Twilighter76 on May 31, 2009 at 5:20pm
You know WHAT PEOPLE ARE GOING TO LOVE WHAT THEY WANT ! And for me PERSONALLY I LOVE AND ADORE THE TWILIGHT BOOKS MORE ! Don't come at us for prefering something over something else. TOO ME THE TWILIGHT BOOKS WILL ALWAYS have something in my heart.

Love your Harry but I SURE DO LOVE MY TWILIGHT !

Send this to her or whatever.
Comment by Michelle~ on May 31, 2009 at 5:42pm
with Monkey here. You can like as many series of books as you wish. We all have diff taste in what we enjoy but the one thing we have in common here is we are Twilight saga fans.
Comment by Melissa (Missy) J. on May 31, 2009 at 5:50pm
I agree with monkey all the way. I love Harry Potter and I love Twilight, so im not going to debate on them. They are two different books and are meant for reading and enjoyment. J.K. and Steph didnt intend to write these books to show up the others. They wrote it to tell a story that they wanted to tell. They cannot be compared if they werent meant to be compared in the first place. Enjoy the two series and even more books. Don't debate, just read. And another can debate all you want about which is better, but you don't have to do it on this site. Go to like Myspace or Facebook, start a group and debate it there. Don't go to a site where you KNOW everyone's gotta be Twilight fans and start debating. Go to a a neutral site and do your debating.
Comment by Kelseyyyy on May 31, 2009 at 11:07pm
you say the last three book s are crap. i say the last harry potter books are crap. you can't just drag along a story. say what you say, and don't get pissed when someone says it back.
Comment by Rosalie Lillian Hale on May 31, 2009 at 11:19pm
Would everyone just stop comparing Harry Potter to Twilight and J.K to Stephenie!
They are both 2 completely different people who wrote 2 completely different book series!
Honestly it is just really annoying!
I could say heaps more but I wont!
Comment by Morgaine Chya on May 31, 2009 at 11:29pm
The Potter and Twilight series of books were written for different target demographics. Potter is written to appeal to both genders, and Twilight appeals to mainly females.

But they both appeal to their target audiences, including all ages, and they both serve a significant role as getting young people motivated to pick up a book and read, hopefully creating interest in other books as a result.

For you to say that Potter is better than Twilight would be like me saying a Louis L'Amour western book is better than a bodice-ripper, such as "Skye O'Malley," the tawdry adventure tale of a young woman who has many lusty adventures, including losing her virginity twice (she had a head injury when she was captured by pirates, producing amnesia, and when she was sold to the Whoremaster of Algiers she did not remember she had been married twice, and had three children...all by the age of 18...I only explain this detail because it is one of the best examples of some of the ROFLMAO experiences you have when reading this type of book).

Westerns and bodice-rippers are written for two different target demographics. To compare the two for which is "better" or "worse," without defining the target audience, is like asking someone to say which was better, oranges or lemons, without defining that "better" would mean whether the people who would be eating the two fruits would prefer a more sweeter or sour fruit.
Comment by Morgaine Chya on May 31, 2009 at 11:37pm
Ms. MonkeyMan makes an excellent point. What Harry is doing is not debating.

What Harry is doing is launching a string of logical fallacies in the forms of unsupported, entirely subjective claims.

A debate consists of defining a premise, then presenting credible OBJECTIVE data to support your premise, then drawing the premise through the objective data to reach a conclusion.

That is not what Harry does at all. In addition to his subjective claims, he also makes completely unsupported statements against Twilight fans. That type of logical fallacy is called an "ad hominem" attack, and it is the mark of a very impotent debater who cannot support her/his premise by honest means and so must stoop to dishonest and unethical tactics.
Comment by Mrs.Jacob Black on June 1, 2009 at 6:42am
i dont think u eve read the books if u have u would luv them and harry potter SUCKS if u ask me it doesnt make any sense y u think harry is better than edward harry is a ugly wanna b he is a nobody and twilight will never get old that is because harry is already in the trash at my house if u dont like twilight then get off this page this is called TWIFANS NOT TALK ABOUT TWILIGHT so u need to find a new kind of luv 4 twilight lotz of luv
Comment by Aimee on June 1, 2009 at 10:44am
There's lots I could say, but to bother would be giving this person what they are seeking....attention.
Comment by SherieheartsRob on June 1, 2009 at 11:12am
I totally agree with Monkey. You cant just think that your the only one intitled to an opinion. And you say that the other 2 SM books are "Puke and innopropriate" how are they innopropriate? i dont understand your thoughts on that. And also i loved the HP series, i started reading them when i was 11. But as i got older, the books became a little boring, I read 1,2,3,4 and half of the 5 coz i got bored with it. When the last book came out, i just wanted to find out what happened at the end, all the middle stuff didnt mean anything to me, so i cheated and read the last couple of chapters, and i can say i am completely satisfied with my decision to do so. However, the Twilight series didnt bore me, it intrigued me and i wanted more. And with the 4 books it wasnt too long like HP, it was the right amount. Enough to keep you interested and tell the story without using 7 books to end up with the same conclusion. Anyway, dont be a hater to the people that love something.
Everyone has to be passionate about something and we just happen to be passionate about Twilight!!!


You need to be a member of TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite to add comments!

Join TwiFans-Twilight Saga books and Movie Fansite



© 2016       Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...